Volunteer Spotlight: Moira Caserio’s Legacy of Care and Connection

Oct 16, 2025 | Academic, School News

For four years, Moira Caserio has been a familiar face at Cristo Rey St. Martin, first as a volunteer and now, briefly, as a college counselor, stepping in while Sharon Holdvogt, one of two CRSM college counselors, was on maternity leave. Her last official day is October 3, but her impact on students will be long-lasting.

“I love hearing students’ stories. That is the best part of being a college counselor,” Moira says. “I wish everyone had to write a personal statement. Students are so willing to open up and dig deep, and I really appreciate the trust they place in me during this process.”

She works hard to make the stressful college journey more approachable. “I try to make it fun and comfortable for them. Students are so engaged and willing to participate. It’s a wonderful experience for me, and I hope it is for them as well.”

A recent moment perfectly illustrates her approach. A student who was initially hesitant to trust Moira ended a personal statement session with a high five, a small but meaningful sign of confidence and connection.

Before joining CRSM, Moira was a lawyer and completed a college counseling certificate through UCLA. She also works as an independent education consultant with Tree Street College Consulting. Still, she says the best part of her work is collaborating with Sharon and Ana and helping students grow.

Through her guidance, Moira has demonstrated that college applications can be challenging, rewarding, and even enjoyable. CRSM is deeply grateful that she stepped in during such a critical time for college counseling. Without her support, the tremendous workload would have been a tall order for just one college counselor, and Moira’s presence made all the difference for both students and staff.